With no end in sight to the dispute between the Orange Order and the Garvaghy Road residents, relations between the parties in Northern Ireland continued to deteriorate this week. The opening of the plenary session of the Assembly on Monday 5 October was dominated by statements from MLAs on both sides relating to the standoff, offering condemnation of their opponents and support for their colleagues.
On Monday 12 October, the Assembly will debate a series of motions of no confidence in each of the Sinn Féin ministers in the Northern Ireland Executive – Michelle O’Neill (First Minister), Caoimhe Archibald (Economy), John O’Dowd (Finance), and Liz Kimmins (Infrastructure). The motions are in the names of MLAs from each of the three unionist parties – the DUP, UUP, and TUV.
Anywhere else in the UK or Ireland, such a situation would represent genuine jeopardy for the ministers under scrutiny. However, the consociational model of devolution in Northern Ireland ensures that the motions are set to fail. Under the Good Friday Agreement, any such motion would require cross-community support, meaning that it would need the backing not only of a majority of MLAs voting, but also of a majority of both unionist and nationalist MLAs voting. This model is designed to ensure that one community cannot force its will on the other, even if it has a majority.
A significant consequence of the deadlock between the parties is that they have been unable to agree a budget and a financial package with the Secretary of State, Sir Chris Bryant. As a result, Bryant has instructed officials in the Northern Ireland Office to make contingency plans for a budget for Northern Ireland, a task that ought to fall entirely within the remit of the devolved Executive.
The tensions in the Assembly chamber and around the Executive table look set to continue, making the already challenging task of legislating for a deeply divided community all the more difficult. With elections set to take place in May, the DUP may calculate that it is not in its interest to improve relations with Sinn Féin, for fear of being outflanked by its opponents.
A further complication is that neither of the main party leaders is a member of the Northern Ireland Assembly – the DUP’s Gavin Robinson is a Member of Parliament at Westminster, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald is a member of Dáil Éireann in Dublin. This means that relations between leading figures and party spokespersons are sometimes less familiar than they are between Executive colleagues.
How long the dispute at Drumcree will last remains unclear. However, the damage it has done to relations between the parties has the potential to last until – and possibly beyond – the elections. These events should therefore serve as a timely reminder of the fragility of devolution in Northern Ireland, and of what makes it significantly different from Scotland and Wales.